PDA

View Full Version : CAT Madras judgement dt. 29/12/2010 on OA No.966 of 2009



ankitsud36
27-04-2011, 06:09 PM
Can any one tell about the outcome/implementation on judgement dt.29/12/10 of CAT Madras bench in OA No. 966 and 967 of 2009 regarding grant of GP of 5400 to AAOs of IA&AD.


-Ankit Sud

Victor
27-04-2011, 08:20 PM
Can any one tell about the outcome/implementation on judgement dt.29/12/10 of CAT Madras bench in OA No. 966 and 967 of 2009 regarding grant of GP of 5400 to AAOs of IA&AD.


-Ankit Sud

The judgment is available at (http://www.pafsolink.org/judgement%20(1).PDF). No further information is available at present.

Victor

krishnan09
29-04-2011, 10:04 AM
This verdict is unable to digest and there will be some problem with this judgement. The pre-revised scale of Sr.Accountant is 5500-9000 and on their 2nd financial upgradation, they were given GP5400 and now the same is to be given to AAOs by stepping up of the pre-revised 7450-11,500 of AAOs. In fact the stepping up can be given only those holding the same scale/designation. Now these pre-scales and designations are different. I feel the pre-revised 5500-9000 might have been given 1st upgrdation to 4600 when merged with 6500-10,500 and when further merged with SO and AAO ie., 6500 and 7450 both were placed in GP4800. or at the time of MACP these Sr.Accountant might have been given 5400 GP when they completed 10/20/30 years. Whereas the AAOs also eligible for GP5400 when they complete 4 years (NFS) as was done in income tax. Whereas the CAT directed to step up of the AAO scale at par with their junior cadres. Hence it is difficult to understand the verdict unless there is a further direction from CAT on a revision petition .

krishnan

SASI
29-04-2011, 08:49 PM
Senior Accountants who were recruited as Accountants were granted the Scale of 6500-10500 as second upgradation under ACP upto 31-8-2008. Since the GP of 6500-10500 is Rs.4800 in IA&AD, on implemation of the MACP they were given the third upgradation to the GP of 5400. Whereas the AAOs who are in the supervisory cadre recruited as Clerk Typists have already got three promotions and since NFS Scale is not implemented in IA&AD they remained at the Grade Pay of 4800. That resulted in the case.

sasi